Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Yet another AI bamboozle story

Last week, I had lunch with two old friends, K&K. Old old friends. Friends from high school. So, friends for over 60 years.

They have been together as a couple that long as well, even though we went to high school in a time (1960's) and place (Catholic girls school) where no one even knew that two women could be a couple. 

But they were and are, and I was honored to do a reading at their wedding in 2004, shortly after Massachusetts legalized gay marriage. 

Anyway, we're all great readers, and K1 asked if I'd read Elizabeth Strout's latest novel, The Things We Never Say. I am a fan of Elizabeth Strout, so of course I had. And I enjoyed it, as I have all of her work. Just not as much as I enjoyed Olive Kitteridge, which to me remains her masterpiece. 

Anyway, K1 told me that she had started reading it, and thought it was just awful. Terrible characters. No plot. Chapters that didn't hang together. Lousy writing. She wondered whether Elizabeth Strout had rushed something out to satisfy a book contract. Or perhaps she is unwell.

K2 then said that she, too, had found the book totally lacking.

I said that, while I didn't think it was as good as Olive K, I had enjoyed reading it, and especially liked the portrayal of the teacher's relationships with his high school students. I then something about the way they were describing the book made it sound like AI.

Indeed.

K1 and K2 don't typically buy their books on Amazon.

Like me, they like to support indie booksellers.

But they were in a rush. They needed to read it for their book club, and K2 was heading out of town and wanted to read it on the plane, so K1 ordered it from Amazon. 

There was something strange about the book from the jump.

The author's name on the cover was given as Elizabeth Joy Strout.

"Who knew she had a middle name?" I said.

Indeed.

And there was no author's photo. No mini-bio on the inside of the back flap. Etc.

Turns out that K1, in her haste, had ordered a bogus AI book that used Elizabeth Strout's name and title.

K1 informed Amazon, and they refunded her money and took the fake book down. (But quite cheesily didn't send her the real book gratis. One more reason to despise Amazon.) She also got in touch with Random House, Strout's publisher. 

I'm surprised at how shocked I was to hear this story.

Sure, I knew there was a lot of AI slop being churned out and sold on Amazon, but I wasn't aware that real authors' were being ripped off. The real deals are not only losing revenue, they're being cheated out of readers getting to know their writing. Imagine someone picking up Elizabeth Strout for the first time and finding it a total piece of crap. And, of course, the readers are being cheated as well. Their money is stolen, as is the pleasure that comes from reading a well-written book. 

In my naïveté, I wondered why this wasn't all over the press. I wanted K1 (who is a writer) to write an essay for the NY Times exposing all this. 

But, as it turns out, it's nothing new. It called parasite authorship, and The Atlantic had an article on it a couple of months ago.

Across categories—fantasy, horror, even coloring books—writers say they’re seeing AI-generated listings crop up on their Amazon author pages. Some of these works are in entirely different genres from their usual work—such as a children’s series misattributed to a writer of steamy love stories—whereas others echo the subject matter or jacket designs of preexisting books.
...AI companies pirated millions of books to train today’s most popular models, as The Atlantic has previously reported. Those models are now being used to churn out books in a matter of minutes and place them alongside books that represent years of hard work. In some cases, people go beyond mass-producing second-rate content or publishing copycats of new releases, using the names of established authors on parasitic works that feed off preexisting brands. (Source: The Atlantic)

For the most part, the AI sloppery is a problem for genre writers (e.g., romance authors) who churn out a ton of work that their fans consume on the regular, not caring about whether the book is well written or not. It's read for entertainment. The fast food equivalent of reading a good book. Many of these authors are starting to incorporate AI in their "product," I guess not realizing that those manipuating OpenAI, Meta, Anthropic, et al. can just eliminate the "real" writer totally. After all, they're just intermediaries. (This is why I think that influencing will prove to be a flash-in-the-pan profession. Why should a company pay an influencer when they can concoct their own for next to nothing?)

Anyway, parasite "authorship" is apparently now coming after literary fiction as well.

Authors and publishers are trying to keep on top of it, and Amazon does something or other (not good enough) to clean up their bookshelves. But I guess we've seen the future, and it's more AI sloppery. 

Back off, back the f off, AI bamboozlers. Hands - or whatever it is you use to "write" - off. Leave Elizabeth Strout alone!

----------------------------------------------------------

Image Source: Goodreads

1 comment:

Ellen said...

Wow! I’m incensed. I wonder what Elizabeth Stroud would have to say about this!